Leadgentic Reviews 52

Unfortunately, my experience was very disappointing. Communication was a major issue—they would go weeks without any updates or responses, which made it difficult to trust the process or track progress.

While you may see activity like views and likes on Facebook, it comes at the cost of maintaining a high ad budget, and in my case, it resulted in very few actual leads. Ultimately, we spent over $20,000 with little to no return on investment.

Another concern is that they used our business as an example of a “successful outcome” without our consent, which was very frustrating and unprofessional.

Also, be aware that if you try to cancel early, there are significant penalties—around $7,000—so make sure you fully understand the contract before signing.

I strongly recommend proceeding with caution. My loss can hopefully help someone else avoid the same situation.

God bless.

We’ve had a great experience working with this creators collective. Their team is professional, responsive, and truly understands how to help our business grow. They consistently deliver creative strategies and measurable results, and communication has always been smooth and efficient. We’re very happy with the partnership and highly recommend their services to any company looking to improve their marketing and brand presence

Before our collaboration with Leadgentic, we were technically open to multiple markets yet lacked predictable growth due to ongoing variability caused by Groupon traffic, bargain hunters and inconsistent lead quality that made it difficult to scale in a profitable and sustainable fashion.

However, after teaming up with Leadgentic, this has all changed. Rather than still chasing short-term promotions, we are now strategically entering into new markets with real structure behind our expansion strategy.

Additionally, we have now successfully launched in three new consistently profitable markets, and we are in two more upcoming launches, with each launch having been smoother and more successful than the previous one.

Leadgentic took our existing website and rebuilt it; improved our brand image, and most importantly, began getting us ranked organically on Google in the new markets that generate long-term revenues. The combination of both paid and organic acquisition, combined with true operational strategy makes this feel much more like a true partner committed to achieving mutual success than a typical marketing agency. What stands out as most important is the scalability.

We are no longer dependent upon discounts or unpredictable lead sources, but rather we are building a sustainable business, market-by-market, with momentum on our side.

If you are serious about expanding properly, and are looking for a team committed to driving genuine business growth, not just leads, Leadgentic does just that.

Jon Mandel
President
Safe Auto Glass

We have been working with Leadgentic for the past six months, and one of the best ways to describe them is true to their word. They promised that we would be set up with them faster than anyone in the industry and that they will generate leads no issue. Within just one week of partnering with them, they were running ads across Google and all our social media platforms. They did mention it might take a month or two to start seeing traction, but that was the only thing they lied about. Within a month of starting, we experienced a massive influx of leads. Now, six months in, we are making significant growth moves to handle the incoming leads. I couldn’t recommend them enough! We are grateful to know them!

This company makes false promises of delivering 2x your revenue or they'd "work for free". Not only did our leads and revenue drop by nearly double, our service was completely interrupted with no prior notice or updates until I communicated first, after 2 weeks. After you send the severance letter, they'll ghost you for months then spring on your with an attempt to collect. Positively abhorrent people to work with. Very predatory. Please, for you and your wallet's sake, try absolutely anyone else and stay as far away as possible.

if you care about your people and business, trust me these are your guys. I cant explain to you the difference they have made for me

We took our ads from 0 to 1, and the Leadgentic guys took it from 1 to 100 in a matter of months. Trust these guys with our whole lead gen funnel now!

This has been the best decision i've made for my business. They have consistently performed what they said they were going to and has given us direction in our business. Would recommend Them 100 time over.

These guys are the real deal. My business sales have sky rocketed, I don't need to spend any time on marketing because these guys handle everything A-Z. Even my SEO, I have 91 reviews now and i rank the top 3 on google when someone searches up anything related to ecu tuning. I am beyond happy and I don't think there is any other marketing company that delivers results like these guys.

From the very first conversation, it was clear these guys actually get what it’s like to build something from the ground up. No fluff, no agency-speak bs.

They walked us through every step, made the whole process easy to understand, and treated our brand like it mattered. Once ads went live, they scaled intelligently, optimized proactively, and kept communication tight the entire time. As a founder, that level of clarity and partnership is rare.

Our expectations have been exceeded across the board... If you want an agency that feels like an extension of your team, this is the one.

My experience with Creators Collective / Leadgentic / Creators Consulting has been highly disappointing, and I want to share the facts of what occurred so other business owners can make informed decisions.

According to the contract, SMS was to be billed at $0.0079, and each per minute call at $0.0040 for each call was the agreed rate. However, our account was charged approximately $0.058 per SMS and per minute call. an increase of nearly eight times the contracted amount. I really wish they allowed uploads here. We were also promised a free month of service, which never occurred.

When I raised these concerns, I did not receive a clear explanation. Instead, I was told the issue was caused by automations from my previous agency—a claim I verified as false through multiple independent sources. Our prior agency did not have rebilling enabled, and even if they had, resolving those issues would reasonably fall under the responsibilities of the company we were paying.

Regarding performance, our business consistently generated $60,000–$70,000 per month before hiring this company. After nearly two months with them—and over $5,000 in retainer fees, plus additional ad spend and rebilling overcharges—we received only two leads. One lead could not be located, and the second was mishandled by their setter. Fortunately, my team was able to recover that sale independently.
When I raised these issues again, I was removed from the Slack channel without warning, despite being the business owner and the person responsible for approvals and communication. At that point, I told my team member to request an immediate transfer of our account. The company then required him to agree not to dispute any charges before releasing our account assets—including customer data and conversations—that we originally owned. This was extremely concerning, as access to our own data should never be contingent upon waiving our rights.

I believe in professionalism, transparency, and honoring contractual agreements. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this company. I am pursuing the appropriate steps to ensure accountability, and I encourage any business owner considering their services to proceed with caution.

If others have experienced similar issues, feel free to reach out.

These guys were crazy helpful. I run several car detail shops and they 4x my appointments and also helped guide me in upselling when customers come in. 10/10 recommend.

This team is top tier!! I’ve used many ads companies before and it’s never worked to this extent! These guys are the real deal!! Me and my husbands company has 3x in monthly revenue the last four months!

Here’s the thing: if you want to move fast, go alone; if you want to go far, go together. Leadgentic is built on that idea. They meet you where you are and help you get where you actually want to go. But remember, it is a two way street. You do not get to outsource your effort. You carry your weight, they carry theirs.

Communicate. Replicate. Then iterate. That is how you scale. Leadgentic has helped grow a lot of shops because they focus on skill, not hype. This is not a get rich quick play. It is a long term game with a massive upside if you show up, do the work, and keep doing it. No lip service. Just action.

Stop living the same six months on repeat. It is time to scale your business so you can start working on it instead of drowning in it.

My experience has been nothing but amazing. Don’t listen to the troll reviews. I could almost guarantee its people that weren’t patient enough, or don’t know how to run their own business! I hope this review finds people well. It has helped me skyrocket at my business and the best way possible!

I came into Creators Collective/Leadgentic with high hopes. I got sold the dream, was willing to pay the premium, and got onboarded.

Started off a little rocky with slow onboarding and high lead cost, but things started to improve. Got down to $30-35 on google ads. Meh. Not great. It was up and down. Some weeks we would have lead costs in the 40s, other times mid 30s. BUT to their credit, overall their google search campaign throughout the entire time i used them ended in an average CPL of 31.03, which still kinda sucks for the margins of my service, but to their credit there was some lower lead costs in there to balance it back down to that number overall.

But Meta? Dear God. Don't get me started on Meta. It was an absolute trainwreck. Lead costs were consistently 50, 70, 40, and over 100 dollars. 100 DOLLARS FOR A LEAD? For reference, the overall CPL for meta on the entire ad account for the time I used them was $50.45. Not good.

Here's the kicker.

I was the main account manager, not them. I was always keeping tabs on all of my ads and asking questions, not them. I was asking if we could split test different creative, not them. I was the one cancelling the 40, 50, 70, and 100 dollar ads, not them.

This made me so upset.

Dream Outcome: "For 1700 dollars a month we will manage all of your ads, give sales feedback, and double your revenue."

Reality: "We are going to waste lots of time and mishandle tens of thousands of dollars in ad spend."

Now I'm a reasonable guy. Please don't think I'm going all Karen over here. This is just my plea to anyone who may be considering using their service, especially for auto glass.

The auto glass industry by nature is low ticket high volume. Our company's price is on the higher end of the spectrum, like all good and reputable companies do. To give clear numbers, our typical gross profit on a standard windshield or glass replacement is 275, we flat rate labor over the cost of glass.

Let's breakdown the 275 we're working with.

It costs us about 100 bucks to do a job. This pays for tech to knock out the job, including gas, insurance, hourly, and job materials.

Now we're at 175. Still not bad. But lets factor in customer acquisition, at CC's best lead cost, which was about 30 bucks. At a 25% close rate, which is an average close rate given the type of customer you get on a google ad response for a service like this, we would have an acquisition cost of $120.

Now we're left with 55 bucks to run the business. Ouch.

Let's calculate what that looks like at a $50 lead cost shall we? Simple math. now we're at $200 customer acquisition with a $175 margin after direct job costs. What are we left with? -$25

Here's the problem.

We have negative money.

So we're losing money just to do the jobs.

And this was the problem.

Other jobs with more margin with calibrations we were able to make money on, but these jobs we were just spinning our wheels.

They blamed me for not being able to close enough of the jobs, saying that's why I was losing money. I had a long conversation with Justus, who claimed we missed 40% of calls, which on record we missed 4, but truly we only missed 1, which we called back immediately (within seconds) afterwards.

How do I know for sure my team called them back within seconds? I downloaded my T Mobile Call history to make sure. Because when Justus told me that I said I would look into it and I did. And he was full of crap just like I knew he was.

So it's not like we were mistreating our leads. By the way, the other 3 missed calls on record were 1. A repeat call after we booked the job, 2. Called at 9:47 pm which we returned the following morning, and 3. Someone who called but only wanted to communicate through text.

What my study also showed me was 9 other spam calls that i paid $30+ for which further increases my actual CPL, because they don't have fraud blockers.

Oh yeah, and let's not forget, in addition to high lead costs, we're paying them $1,700/mo

So I bring my findings to Justus and he ignored me.

Didn't care. Just wanted to charge me another monthly fee to cancel, which at the end of the day, is fair. Why? Because i signed a contract and agreed to the terms. I was just hoping for some compassion given the evidence I brought him but as he said, "a contract is a contract." Which is true.

Which sucks, but hey, I looked at it this way, either I pay them $1700 to get them out of my business, or I let them keep ruining everything.

I promise I'm not being dramatic.

When you're watching your business burn right before your eyes and you have 2 months with NEGATIVE INCOME instead of positive income, you know there's a huge problem.

So here it is, my long awaited review.

I used them from mid March to the end of June, and ended my 6 month contract early so that I could cut my losses and get away from them.

I was going to post photos of my ad account but it appears i can't on this page.

Hire at your own risk ;)

Warning: Do Not Use This Ad Agency

I’ve been working with this company for almost a year. Things started off ok, but after about six months, everything went downhill. They promised to work for free if they couldn’t meet certain goals — but that never happened.

I ended up losing thousands of dollars, and I want to make sure others don’t make the same mistake. There were countless errors, poor communication, and no accountability when things went wrong.

This company preys on small businesses because they think they can take advantage of them. Please be cautious and don’t fall into their trap.

Didn’t even use them and there sending me harassing emails this place is a big scam ever use them stay far away

If you look at marketing as a vending machine you can simply purchase leads from, then Leadgentic isn't for you.

If you are wanting to make an investment into your company, then trust that they will bring a team of dedicated people to help you grow.

Their team members work to learn your company and industry to ensure they provide the best service. If you have any questions about our experience with them feel free to reach out. Eye Kandy Customs Olive Branch, MS

After my first conversation with Leadgentic I knew I wanted to use their service. It took me some time to finally pull the trigger, but I'm so glad I did. It has helped me grow my business significantly faster than I would have been able to do it alone.