Mtgproxy Reviews 639

Great quality, great value

Easy interface. Top quality cards. Quality shipping

The proxies are of good quality and they get shipped out to you fast. Would recommend to anyone who’s doing deck testing.

MTGproxy.com has been an excellent resource for high-quality Magic: The Gathering proxies. I use their service to help offset the cost of some of the more expensive cards I want to run in my decks, and the results have been fantastic. Their website is intuitive and easy to navigate, making the ordering process simple and straightforward. The print quality is some of the best I’ve seen—crisp images, great color, and a very professional finish. I’ve really enjoyed using their service and will absolutely continue to use MTGproxy.com for any future proxy needs.

They do good work, are prompt, and are exceptionally friendly.

Cards look great and arrived quickly. Two thumbs up. :)

The website to order proxy Magic cards is very easy to follow and set up your deck to exactly the style you'd like down to which edition art style. My only grievance is that there is no rush delivery option, but that's a first world problem. I'll live with waiting. Highly recommended.

I've now ordered a second batch of cards with them. The first was for 120, this time it was for 260. Quality is still great, especially with their new "self-grading" system. I used every card that is labeled 85% quality or better. I even ordered a double sided card and it came out great!
The cards do feel very slightly different than originals, but not enough to make a difference in a deck. I recommend these cards if you are looking to save money on some of those high card priced. 10/10 will buy again in the future.

Okay so first these aren't high quality by any means but that is to be expected honestly for the price they arwnt bad. Now for my issue I've ordered from them a few times and they always shipped very quickly but this last time its been weeks and the order still hasn't even shipped yet so I've reached out to them twice now to try and see when I can expect my order and really they have been un helpful with it. After this experience I cant say that I recommend using them because their customer service is basically non existent and there are definitely better options out there (though those places are more expensive)

Edit/Update - Pretty disappointed with shipping. Specifically went through them because they had fast shipping and turn around. We're coming up on two weeks with still no cards in sight.
Cards were done printing 2 days after order was placed and took over a week to get out and ship. Then a delay with the delivery on top. Cards are great and price is the same as everywhere. I would say order cards from here but don't expect them any faster than the other proxy sites.
Cards have been great in the past. This is the second time I am ordering with them! I save up enough cards on a list till i want to order a big bunch then get that nice discount! Overall very pleased! I don't remember how long the shipping took the first time but i don't recall being upset about it.

Great quality product and very easy to use.

Awesome, has got me back into paper magic with my mates. Love it!

Love the work and customer service they provided. The cards I ordered were made accurately and very well done.

Theyre quick, efficient and the prints always look amazing. Ive used them for many custom cards and always enjoy the results

A fantastic company providing a fantastic product with fantastic pricing and fantastic customer service. Seriously. Their pricing can't be beat. The proxies look great, often matching or beating the quality of the original. They send you updates when they get the order, finish printing, ship, and deliver.

I proxied a few of the most expensive cards for my girlfriend's AC deck, and I was hooked. No hassle, no headache, no waiting on a dozen envelopes, no missing orders, flat rate 5$ shipping, it's light years better for casual players.

Great company and always arrives safe and sound. Glad it’s a resource to make the game affordable to all!

The cards are very high quality! My only gripe with my order was I got a double sided card (Etali) with a foil upgrade. The upgrade only counted for one side of the card which wasnt specified so now it kinda looks weird if I flip it over and it isnt foil. Still very high quality and that is just a minor complaint. Great product!

Only great experiences with this company. Impressively making the game we love more affordable and allows the ability to have high quality place holders.

Thanks again. Highly recommended.

Honestly, these proxies look great, the shipping was good and not too slow and not too expensive. I think they charge a decently fair price for the quality.

Just put in my 2nd order. Wedsite is easy to use, and the cards are of excellent quality.