Mtgproxy Reviews 639

Great quality and customer service. My custom cards looked amazing.

I've order a couple of times from these guys, the quality of the cards have been fantastic for the price. The cards look and feel great, so much so I forget there proxies when they are in sleves. On top of all that the turn around time on printing and shipping has been great, my most recent order shipped out 2 days after ordering and is already going to be here before my next EDH night.

All of the reviews on here are "prompted", the owner begs people via email to come here and write these reviews. I suspect many are also fake. The proxy cards he produces are mid-grade at best. I have ordered 1000's of cards, and in every case about 50% are "acceptable" and the rest are just trash quality. Of course if you complain about the poor quality, he blames YOU for "choosing a bad image" to print on the card from the selection given on the website, even though you spent literally hours choosing the "highest rated" quality images for each card. Its just a matter of course that the vast majority of provided MTG card images on the site are straight trash. If you attempt to upload your own high quality images, you are blocked by the site's tiny file size limits. If you go into the site's Discord server to share your negative experience with the poor quality cards and bizarre website printing restrictions, you get verbally berated and harassed by the owner and eventually banned from the Discord. The owner of this company is extremely childish and unprofessional. I am not gonna waste any more time or money on this site and this dude's garbage cards. I now have enough trash bulk MTG proxies to last me a lifetime so I can focus on collecting higher quality items from printers who know what they are doing, and dont berate their customers and delete negative feedback from their discord server 😂

I got a little over 100 cards for a deck I wanted to try out and the vast majority of them looked great.

Fantastic card quality and customizable backs! They even have alternate arts and custom arts for most cards. I will be using them again when I decide to make more poor life choices.

Great customer service and a great product
Would highly recommend.

10/10 service, will order again until I have every card I want.

Great quality and platform. Quick shipping. Overall a great experience!

Overall this is an excellent business to order magic the gathering proxies from. I've ordered about 1,800 cards from them now. Only one of those had a printing error (slightly off-center). Some old darker cards are very hard to read, because of low contrast, but that is rare. It helps to pick brighter, higher-quality printings from among the options for each card. Shipping is pretty fast.

Incredible customer service that immediately resolved a shipping issue that was due to USPS. Cards shipped very quickly. Would recommend.

Cheaper by ordering in bulk AND the widest selection of all art printings and custom art options? It's too good to ignore once your pod is okay with using proxies to keep each other from breaking the bank.

Even found a number of art editions I never knew existed that looked better than the physical copies I'd bought, so this also helps protect your decks and your cardboard investments. Just a solid company all around.

High quality proxies with various options as custom art and custom card backs while disallowing the offical card back so no concerns about intentionally hiding the legitimacy of the cards.

Quick simple and easy to use

Always a great product also love my dry erase cards ❣️

Site is extremely easy to use. Type in the card/cards you would like proxy'd and the exact card and a plethora of arts to choose from come up immediately and they are fairly cheap, even more so when you buy in bulk. Would reccomend if looking for good proxies

My order was filled promptly. They came in and were clearly good quality cards with crisp images a nice weight to them. The edges are well cut and I'm quite happy with them. Thank you MTGProxy.

I was always a little nervous about ordering proxy’s thinking about what the quality is gonna be but mtgproxy’s does an amazing and quick job for high quality cards I wouldn’t use any other company.

Great quality, great pricing, fast shipping. Brings back the joy of cracking packs without the terrifying realization that you're being extorted for over-inflated pieces of cardboard. 10/10

The card printing quality is great and the pricing for the cares are very affordable!

Highly recommend buying from them if you are looking to get back into magic or test trial an expensive commander deck.