Proxyprinters Reviews 16

The cards I got were all well made and exceeded my expectations for what they were. Sadly they need to improve their customers service. My order was missing a few cards and when I reached out to them I was made to feel like I was try cheat them out of product. I sent them pictures of the cards I had and made a list of the cards I was missing. They gave me a refund but after telling me they knew for a fact the shipment was checked before it left. I'm not a fan of the customer is always right, but when a customer send everything you asked for, and was willing to jump through hoops, to get a refund and or replacement. It's possible that something was missed, and making a customer feel like a thief for asking for replacements is wrong.
On top of that it also took for ever for my order to arrive, I'm putting faith in them and saying every card is made when the order is placed, So that was what slowed up shipping.

Honestly not sure why there are bad reviews. The proxies I got are great quality — black core, clear print, and exactly what I needed to play with. Some people just expect perfection for custom cards, but for the price these are awesome. Super affordable and the customer service was really solid too. I’d definitely order again.

The quality is not good. You can certainly use them if you want to have a very obviously bad proxy. I certainly find it laughable that at this time the cards that look like they are foil are actually printed with a rainbow gradient on a non-foil card to represent a foil. Laughable and embarassing.

I feel tricked, and really should have placed a smaller test order I suppose. But I had such a good luck with other companies up until now. I even know people tha make foils at home and their home brewed proxies are so much better than these. I don't understand how you can have a business with such terrible quality.

I tried to reach out to tell them my feedback and get some kind of resolution but never heard a thing. I will not buy from them again. Try Tolarian Library or Proxy Ninja for an established company that knows how to print properly.

Order for a bunch of cards placed on 2025-05-13, which is 3 weeks ago. It still hasn't shipped. A week ago, I reached out to them to ask about the delay but received no communication back.

It looks like it used to be a reputable company but has now gone downhill completely.

I will wait another week and then file a chargeback with my card, and will never order again.

Company is a joke. Took forever to send my order and sent me a bunch of random cards that were some of the worst quality proxies I had ever seen. They just threw together the package so they could provide shipping proof to PayPal against the dispute I filed against them.

The customer service is great, their selection is massive, and the prices are good. Unfortunately what they fall sort on is the quality of the cards. They advertise high quality proxy cards but you can clearly tell that they're fake by the fading color of them and the rough art on them. You get what you pay for I guess but I can't help feeling slightly disappointed

Such a great company! Be confident to buy with Proxy Printers! They are transparent when answering questions and the product is great quality

Excellent service, got my cards on time

Card quality is great. Highly recommended

Good quality. Great service. Always deliver on time. Fantastic product and great customer service.

My search for a great proxy is over. Proxyprinters delivered! Great cards and service! I will be ordering my cards from these guys in the future. Keep up the good work guys!

I have ordered twice now from proxy printers. Quality is great and I like their speed in communication. I asked about the art for the back of the card prior to ordering and got my response. Excellent service and cards.

The quality of the cards is very poor, the printing is cheap and looks like a pixel graph. The cards are not only fake, they also look like they are. Unplayable cards! There are much better alternatives for proxies!

The quality of the cards is really good. The delivery was also smooth and according to the provided dates.

Top-Quality Proxies and Exceptional Service! I've ordered several Magic: The Gathering proxy cards from Proxy Printers, and I'm consistently impressed by the quality and detail. The cards are virtually indistinguishable from the real thing, with vibrant colors and a premium feel. The ordering process was smooth, and the customer service was top-notch. Shipping was prompt, and the cards arrived well-protected. Whether you're looking to enhance your collection or play without worrying about damage to your valuable cards, Proxy Printers is the way to go. Highly recommend!"

It's the second time I'm buying from this website now and the quality of the cards are really good. They are nearly identical to the original cards, but much cheaper and they help me try out different strategies and "save" the original cards I'd use otherwise.
Quick shipping and good help from customer support when I had some questions - so can recommend this to anyone looking for quality proxy cards to complete their deck, or if you want to try before buying the original cards.