Nine of 12 fish died within 72 hours. Shrimpy Business covered only two
I placed a $132.52 order that included 12 celestial pearl danios for $72.21, a Blue Dream Neocaridina breeder pack for $55.21, and a nerite snail for $5.10.
The order arrived after approximately three weeks, which I understood because the danios were listed as a preorder item. The problem was the condition and rapid mortality of the fish.
One danio was dead on arrival. A second died within 24 hours. Over the following two days, seven more died. In total, nine of the 12 fish (75% of the fish order) were dead within 72 hours of delivery.
The fish were placed in a fully cycled tank where the existing livestock continues to thrive. I reported the dead-on-arrival fish immediately, reported the second death within 24 hours, and contacted customer support again within 72 hours to explain that nine fish had now died.
Their response was:
“Thank you! We processed claim for 2 fish, since only 2 were reported within 24 hours. If you have any questions, please let us know.”
The response contained no questions about the tank, water parameters, symptoms, acclimation, or the condition of the surviving fish. Seven additional deaths were simply excluded because they occurred outside the company’s 24 hour reporting window.
I do not expect a seller to guarantee live fish indefinitely; however, when 75% of a shipment dies within three days while the tank’s existing livestock remains healthy, reasonable customer service should investigate the possibility that the fish arrived severely compromised and offer a meaningful resolution.
Prospective buyers should understand what this policy means in practice: once the first 24 hours have passed, the customer bears the loss, even when most of the fish die almost immediately afterward. Based on the condition of the fish and the company’s rigid, dismissive response, I would not purchase live fish from Shrimpy Business again.
11 augustus 2026
Review zonder uitnodiging