Horsesaddleshop Reviews 

Misrepresentation on the product ordered then they screw you when you try to get refunded. Steer clear of this place.

Ordered a retired Breyer horse from them for a good price. It came extremely well packaged in a pristine box, perfect for any collector. If they have a horse you’re looking for, don’t be afraid to order from them! Also, the packaging smells amazing.

I was looking for a certain product that is very hard to find in Canada. Found it on this website. I should’ve known they were a scam when they said they only took E transfer. Do not order from this company. It’s a fraud. It’s a scam. They take your money. Do not send you any sort of product. scammed me in many out of hundreds of dollars Please beware.

In 2025 I Sent a saddle to be sold a Top quality Circle Y saddle. Circle Y the company itself actually recommends Horse Saddle Shop in Indiana to sell used Circle Y saddles! I was impressed by how easy it was to send the saddle. The company has everything on line you can fill out the paperwork print it for your records request a saddle shipping box and it will arrive quickly. You then wrap your saddle with the bubble wrap in the box place your paperwork inside tape close affix shipping label and take to shipper you choose
That’s it. When it sells you receive an email and all buyers get 30 days to try Saddle fit on their horse after that Horse saddle shop mails you a check pretty simple! A+++
I also purchased a Trail saddle from them and love it!

I ordered products from Horse Saddles Shop and never received them. I tried contacting them a number of times with no response. Please don't buy from this company.

dont buy used saddles from em they make em look much nicer in photos then you get a nasty stained saddle. It didnt fit my horse n I was overcharged for the pos saddle! when I asked later to trade it in for different saddle I just got response sry cant do that i was totally scammed by this company!

Not happy with this company at all!
I ordered a new Billy Cook saddle, and I love the Billy Cooks I’ve been riding in them for years. When it arrived, it had oil stains on the seat and on the saddle that I thought would go away. I rode in the saddle twice and damaged and stained my jeans on both occasions. I sent the saddle back for it to be worked on, then received the saddle again, The look of the saddle looks much better, however, it’s still leaving oil stains on my pants. Very frustrating to pay $2500 for something that stains your jeans. They have never offered a refund because I don’t want the saddle like this. Customer service is very slow to respond to emails.

Sent a nice Simco saddle using there expensive shipping and packing for consignment. Never got paid. When I called to ask about it, they were very rude and bulling. BEWARE OF CONSIGNING!

Fast international delivery ,
Original products.