Thetoastysmore Reviews 

I’ve order twice from her 15 pkg at a time. The product arrives just like she did on TT. The flavors of all of them was spot on. I would recommend to anyone even to cut them up to share or hide in closet like I do

Carolyn

This was my first time ordering from this store. I received my marshmallows in good shape! Packaging was thoughtful and included ice packs. Luckily they held up great despite the hot weather. These are made with real ingredients and even if they had melted I would have appreciated them. They are very delicious!

I appreciate the clean ingredients, the wonderful texture and flavor! Each pack comes with 3 gigantic cubes of marshmallow, which honestly one could slice up in smaller pieces and there would be pleeeeenty! I stocked up on these in the Butter Vanilla flavor for my kids to try roasting their first marshmallows in the backyard, this Summer.

Stephanie, the owner, was very responsive and has been very helpful and PATIENT with my questions <3.

I will definitely be ordering more, a whole sheet, because it is the healthiest option in the market!

My sister turned me on to them. They’re very delicious. They’re excellent for my coffee. I cry when I don’t have them. They’re so good!!🥰

Excellent marshmallows! Quick shipping and friendly owners. Love thetoastysmore!

This is a family owned business. They make the best real marshmallows that are made with organic marshmallow root. They are always making different flavors. I love their cinnamon roll. You can't go wrong trying any They make♥️👌

I recently received my 2nd order of marshmallows and I have yet to be disappointed (which will never happen). Each one literally tastes like the real thing and are so delicious! They have such a wide variety of different flavored marshmallows and the love and care they put into each and every batch is unmatched. REAL INGREDIENTS. GREAT FLAVORS. AMAZING CUSTOMER SERVICE. They are always more than willing to work with anyone if there's an issue with their order. I've personally ordered from them twice and I couldn't be happier with my purchases. They're a small family business and they so deserve to have amazing recognition. There wasn't a flavor that I've tried that I didn't like. Please go show thetoastysmore some love! I definitely recommend!

I’m not even a marshmallow person but these completely changed my mind. I’m honestly hooked and already looking forward to placing my third order! The portions are huge, and the texture is perfect... light and airy while still being nice and full. Every bite is packed with flavor all the way through, not just on the outside. You can really tell they use high quality ingredients and put care into these marshmallows. Even the packaging was excellent! Everything arrived fresh and beautifully presented. Highly recommend.

The toasty smore completed my trip to Ruidoso!! I recently discovered the most amazing marshmallows on Instagram, and I can’t stop raving about them! Not only are they incredibly soft, fluffy, and perfectly sweet, but they’re also made with clean, high-quality ingredients you can actually feel good about in your bone both hot cocoa, s’mores, and or anything you need with several different flavors!!!

Unlike traditional marshmallows loaded with artificial flavors and additives, these have a pure, delicious taste that melts in your mouth. They elevate every treat to the next level.

If you’re looking for a better-for-you indulgence that doesn’t compromise on flavor, these marshmallows are an absolute must-try. Simply delicious!
The owner is simply amazing and I was able to pickup my order but she also provides mail order!

OMG I don't normally eat marshmallows just because but THESE are worth every bite! They are so freaking good the flavors are amazing and are not overly sweet! Plus the owners are so kind and helpful. Will be ordering again!

These marshmallows are AMAZING! I can't say I have just one that is my favorite. The creamy taro, the yummy banana cream pie, cotton candy that melts in your mouth...yum! They aren't made with corn syrup, or artificial colors. Made the old fashioned way. The customer service is wonderful. Don't take my word for it, try them yourself 🥰

Just found her love her videos of making marshmallows so much..... very calming. And they taste great. She's doing a great job as a small business owner great product busts her....... and doesn't get enough recognition. Here it is girllllll

Ordered on March 19th and never received my order. Contacted the company and they said Post office didn't scan and to wait for it to arrive. I continued to ask for assistance since it is now a month since I ordered and she just ignored my emails. All I wanted was a refund and move on. I don't want her product and nothing to do with a company that treats their clients that way. Just help them out and don't blame transportation for the problem without a resolve. Its very poorly run!

Not only is this business run by extremely kind people, but the products are very well made, high quality and delicious. They spare no expense on the quality of their candy and make sure that everybody feels appreciated and loved for supporting them.

One of the best mallows I’ve ever tried!
No corn syrup, gluten free options, no artificial colors, great flavors, great communication, halal beef gelatin, and real MARSHMALLOW root!

I’ve tried almost every flavor and I haven’t found one I didn’t like! If there is ever any problem, Tim and Steph are amazing with helping and figuring out the best recourse! Will forever be ordering mallows from them!

I will be buying mallows from them when I start my farmstand to add into my baked goods that’s how good they are! So excited for my large order i just got!

Sooo flavorful! Amazing sizes, not extremely powdery like most homemade mallows are!

These marshmallows are the best on the market! Real marshmallows root, no corn syrup, natural colors, and halal beef gelatin!

I have loved every flavor she has so far. Although my top flavor right now is passion fruit. Something about those homemade sprinkles gets me every time.

You can tell these are made with love and her whole family pitches in too. I will never buy store brand marshmallows again. They package your order live and they provide so much care into making sure your marshmallows get there safe. And if for whatever reason they don’t. She’s so fast at getting you a replacement or refund right away.

The Toasty Smore – Overall Company Review
I’ve bought so many batches from this company that I’ve lost count. Coffee, Hot Chocolate, Blueberry Cheesecake, Cookies & Cream, Taro, key lime, s’mores, birthday cake, peppermint—you name it, I’ve tried it. Every flavor tastes real, not fake, and the texture is always soft without falling apart. These are not basic store marshmallows; they’re actually made with care and they show up tasting the way they’re supposed to.
Shipping has always been solid, packages arrive in good condition, and you can tell this is a small business, not some giant factory trying to sneak cheap ingredients in. Compared to other companies charging three or four times the price for the same‑size marshmallows and half the flavors, this place is a steal.
As for the one bad review I saw, that’s why I wrote this. If my order ever came messed up, I’d call or message them first and see if we can fix it, not jump straight to one star and call them liars or “false advertising.” If I gave my kid a piece of candy and he didn’t like it, that’s on him, not on the company burning to the ground. A little common sense goes a long way. That one lady doesn’t know what she’s talking about—there are over 30 flavors, and every marshmallow clearly has its own real flavor; she’s just a bitter harasser looking for free candy.
For anyone wondering if this company is real and worth it: yes it is. Great flavors, great texture, and a real small‑biz owner behind it. If you’re tired of paying double for less, this is the place.

Absolutely horrible! You buy flavored marshmallows and you receive marshmallows with no flavor! And then the owner calls you abusive and you only want free candy! NO! Your false advertising! Would absolutely NEVER buy again!

WOW!! If you want gourmet marshmallows and PHENOMENAL service then this is where to go!! Absolutely amazing marshmallows!! You will NEVER touch a store bought mallow again after having these delights!! Wonderful people,wonderful products and wonderful service!! These guys are THEE TRIPLE THREAT💙💙💙