Andy&Sarahs Reviews 

Couldn't fault this company. 18th Birthday cookie for grandson and his partner. One doesn't like cake , the other a vegetarian. They were so pleased with the double cookie. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed it, even those who don't like cake! Well decorated. Extremely well packed, and delivered promptly by Royal mail. So nice to have a photograph so we could see the finished product without opening it. Even the hotel staff were well impressed. Would recommend this company without hesitation

This was the first time ordering from Andy & Sarah's. We ordered from the US for our son's birthday who now lives in the UK. Cookie cakes were a tradition in our family for birthdays growing up. Ordering through the Andy & Sarah's website was simple and smooth. They had exactly what we needed. The order was made by next day and shipped arriving in perfect condition. In addtion, the communications sent by A&S during the creation and shipping process of the order was outstanding. Great experience all around.

great products ( a bit overpriced but I guess this also reflects high ratings but still ....not justified!?!)
Since I am rating their services here you deserve 5* for that though:-)

Absolutely amazing service from this company. First time using them, after reading reviews decided to order a cookie for friends 40th birthday. Customer service is second to none, kept me updated on cookie being baked, dispatched, sent me a photo as it was a gift and I might not see it. 5* will definitely use Andy&Sarah’s again.

This was my first order and it was a gift for a friend. The process was quick and easy. It arrived on time and I was updated all the way. They sent my a photo of the brownie since I wasn't going to see it for myself so I really appreciated that. My friend tells me it was delicious. Would definitely order again

This was my first order from Andy and Sarah's. Fudge selection was delicious, the best I've tasted. Lovely flavours and very creamy, not too sweet. Delivery was within a couple of days and was able to track. Will definitely order again and highly recommend. Thank you!

This is the second time we have ordered from Andy and Sarahs and we will order again!
We have had giant cookies and brownies and they never disappoint!
Would highly recommend… thank you A & S !!! Xxxx

I’ve brought a bunch of cookies over the years from andyandsarahs and they somehow get better everytime. The cookies are the best I’ve ever tasted. Delivery is extremely quick for customising a gift too.

I'm so glad I discovered this company. This is the second time I've ordered from them and they keep you up to date with the whole process. I ordered a cookie on the Tuesday and the following day it was received in Ireland ! I appreciate a delivery that swift may not always be possible but the recipient loved getting the cookie and most importantly loved the taste ! I'd like to order myself one 😂

Fantastic service
Fantastic gluten free cookie cake.
Thankyou so much

I came across Andy&Sarahs from a google search and placed my first order in January for a loaded cookie for a family member’s birthday and WOW! we were all amazed at the quality and taste - how perfect that the cookies are properly sealed and stay fresh for so long too! It was so easy ordering and my order arrives so fast. The cookie was probably the best cookie I’ve ever had! I ordered another one recently for another family members birthday and tried the fudge too and it was also amazing. I will definitely be buying all birthday cookies for friends and family from Andy&Sarah’s in the future!!!

Super easy to order, free super fast delivery.
Looked amazing. (They were a gift so didn't get to taste)
Ordered a gluten free and a vegan, both recipients very pleased.
Excellent communication all round. Even got a photo of the cookie.
All tracked by Royal Mail
Cheers 👍🏻

Second order from these guys. Both recipients say they were delicious!
I love supporting small businesses as they give that little extra care!

Absolutely amazing service from this company. Soooo impressed-can’t rate them highly enough. Will definitely be ordering again. Perfect 🤩

I ordered a giant gluten free brownie for my son’s birthday. Ordered after reading the good reviews and I wasn’t disappointed. Prompt delivery and very well packaged. Tasted fresh and delicious. Son and the rest of the family were very impressed. Also lovely iced Happy Birthday message just as I asked for. Will definitely use again thank you.

This is the second time I have ordered from Andy & Sarah and I cannot praise them enough. I love their thoughtfulness in sending a photo of the finished cookie as otherwise I wouldn't get to see it as sent as a gift, although its for my daughter by the time I see her at the weekend I doubt if there will be any left

The recipient was over the moon and said it tasted delicious. Super speedy delivery and communication since purchase exceptional. They even send you a photo of your personalised item if you wish. Just amazing. Will promote and purchase again. Thankyou x

Fantastic tasting cookie, arrived on time and was all in one piece. I asked them to draw a baby yoda on it if possible and they did!

I ordered a pizza sized Double Chocolate chip cookie for our Grandson's 7th birthday! He was moonstruck, thoroughly enjoyed it! Plus it was personalised not only with his name but wee footballs and that did it for him!
The whole experience from ordering online to the actual delivery was all made very easy. Thank you Andy & Sarah very much for an easy stressfree experience! Always difficult when ordering overseas, but not anymore! A big thank you again!

I ordered a gluton free cookie for my friends 30th birthday and we can honestly say it was the best gluton free biscuit we have ever tasted! And beautifully presented thankyou so much Andy and Sarah