I studied with Keats for 6 weeks
I studied with Keats for 6 weeks, opting not to go to their headquarters in Kunming, but instead to travel across four locations. I'm going to review the reaching, travel/immersion, and the value for money components separately.
Teaching:
I thought the quality of the teaching was very good. Tailored to my level, and goals. And also I left some feedback halfway though about how I wanted to change things up which was really quickly acted upon. I don't think my teacher could have done much more - the only thing that I felt made the learning less interesting was that we basically did a textbook front-to-back, and it includes a lot of vocabulary that you wouldn't need in adult life (names of classrooms etc.) and the texts are pretty uninspiring. Really not the end of the world though, there might just not be a great textbook out there and HSK 2-3 doesn't give a lot to work with perhaps. My teacher was happy to tell me which parts were and were not important.
Travel/Immersion:
The idea behind doing it like I did, is to get more immersion and see more. I think this is probably true, but in the end I wsh I hadn't done it this way. Unless you are very extroverted or your Chinese level is quite good, you may end up with quite a lonely solo travelling experience. I felt like my experience would have been better staying in one place and joining some local clubs, though I do think there's a risk of you stay in Kunming that you just chat in English with other students.
The day trips were very tiring after 6 weeks. I ended up not going most days after a few weeks. Some locations have less to offer so bear that in mind. I also wouldn't expect a lot out of these, they are mostly wandering around a temple or a market street, nothing you couldn't find yourself.
There are the Saturday trips which are "bigger" but these are basically the most touristy things where you'll just end up around too many people all photographing the same thing. I felt that almost all the Saturday trips were regrettable, but if you're someone who wants to tick everything off then you'll probably like it.
Value:
This is where unfortunately I felt quite let down by the experience. Ultimately the cost was about £1000 per week (£166 per day, excluding Sunday which is a travel or rest day) and for that you get:
- very poor accomodation, around £15-25 per night but will vary depending on location
- just Saturday trips included in the cost
- 4 hours of teaching per day (1:1)
- occasionally a taxi here and there
- a teacher travelling with you
I thought this premium cost would lead to a better experience ultimately. When I was doing day trips with my teacher, a couple of times they did not join me to avoid paying the ticket price. Also they would encourage us to take public transport on the way to tourist sites and I would pay for the taxi back. These taxis were normally around £1-2. Feels odd to try to save such a small amount.
Only in two of the four locations was there dedicated study space - in the other two we were in cafes. In one hotel in Lijiang we studied for a few days in the freezing cold in the hotel owners dining room. Again this was quite disappointing.
Towards the end of the trip I booked my own hotel for the last week, and I asked my teacher to taxi over to my accomodation's lobby to study rather than go to the schools location, not expecting it to be very good. My teacher was happy enough to come along but I needed to offer to pay the taxi fare for this. It wasn't a lot, and I don't mind, but this just felt very cheap to me given that I had at this point skipped two Saturday trips and probably 15 day trips at this point which would have incurred the school a much larger expense than a few taxi fares.
Ultimately I wouldn't recommend it if you have the means to get your own visa and find an independent tutor. Based on how my teacher was being with saving money, I get the sense that the school is taking a very healthy margin by putting you in cheap accomodation, paying the teachers poorly, and encouraging them to cut costs as far as possible.
Note: Keats did not reach out to me to provide feedback which I think is a bit of a miss from them







