Malcolm C Foy & Co Reviews 

Fantastic help and support from start to finish

Jessica and the team are exemplary and a true picture of competent solicitors who put the clients needs first, have excellent communication and hold themselves to impeccable standards. Would 100% recommend and have nothing but the very best things to say about the team. Made the house buying process as easy as possible and so smooth. Amazing!

Jessica Brooks and her team have been nothing short of fantastic throughout our home buying process. Everything was completed in a timely manner and it made it so much less stressful!

I cannot recommend Jill McKay enough. From start to finish, she handled my case with total professionalism, clear communication, and genuine care. Legal matters can feel overwhelming, but she explained everything in plain English and kept me updated every step of the way. Truly fantastic service—thank you!

I had an excellent experience with the Nick Pashley and Kelly Smith, throughout the conveyancing process. They were extremely professional, approachable, and always easy to communicate with whenever I had a question or needed an update.

They kept everything well organised, explained the process clearly, and responded promptly to my queries. Most importantly, they completed the conveyancing and completion on time, which made the whole process much less stressful.

I really appreciate their attention to detail, professionalism, and commitment to getting everything completed smoothly and on schedule. I would highly recommend their services to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy conveyancing solicitor.

My divorce has finally completed and I could not have done it without the outstanding support from Andrea Pashley and Olivia Hall. Their expertise and knowledge goes beyond the realms of the traditional divorce solicitor. They were empathetic, compassionate and picked me up in some of my darkest hours. They held my hand throughout the process and I am sincerely grateful for the incredible service I received. To end up at the situation of divorce is hard for anyone and I can truly say that these two ladies went above and beyond throughout my journey. If you are looking for a divorce solicitor, look no further, these ladies are miracle workers!

Malcolm C Foys solicitors ( MCF) are 100% the best solicitors that I have used, very knowledgeable, very efficient and took all the worry away from me.
I shall always recommend MCF , I always felt that they were in control and had my best interests at the heart of everything they have done for me.

Would highly recommend working through Donna Moore at Malcom C Foy & Co. She was extremely helpful throughout the whole process of purchasing my first property and made everything clear and straightforward from start to finish.

We recently used MCF Legal for the purchase of our new-build home, and Donna handled everything for us brilliantly. Buying a home can be a stressful process, but Donna made it feel far more manageable, and completion went through without a hitch. We’re very grateful for all her help and would happily recommend MCF Legal to anyone buying a home.

I recently completed my first home purchase with Malcolm C Foy & Co, and I couldn't be happier with the service I received.

From start to finish, the team was professional, helpful, and supportive. They kept me informed and answered my questions
Thank you to Donna, Kelly, and everyone at Malcolm C Foy & Co for your hard work and support. I would happily recommend their services to anyone looking for a reliable and professional solicitor.

We have bought our first house and used Olivia Roger’s as our solicitor, she has been amazing, helped with any questions we have had and really quick at getting back to emails, very professional would 100% recommend a really good company to deal with

I recently completed my first home purchase and was supported throughout the process by my solicitors
Ms. Donna More and Ms. Kelly, who delivered an exceptional standard of service. As a first‑time buyer, I had many questions and uncertainties, but every query was addressed promptly, clearly, and with genuine patience.

Their communication was consistent and transparent, ensuring I always understood each stage of the transaction. Documents were handled efficiently, deadlines were met without delay, and I felt reassured knowing that all legal aspects were being managed thoroughly.

I am grateful for their professionalism, attention to detail, and calm guidance during what can be a stressful journey. I would confidently recommend their services to anyone purchasing a property, especially fellow first‑time buyers.

I first met Olivia Rodgers a few years ago and followed her career as she became a qualified solicitor. She was my obvious choice when I was selling my house. She kept me informed and was quick to answer any questions from the buyers. She is professional and I highly recommend her. Good luck Olivia

Trustpilot Review

Disappointing experience for a first-time buyer

Unfortunately, my experience with this conveyancing firm was extremely disappointing, particularly as a first-time buyer who needed clear communication and guidance throughout the process.

My emails were often ignored, and I received very little guidance or support. I was never able to speak directly with the solicitor handling my case, even when I wanted to raise concerns and make a formal complaint. This left me feeling frustrated and unsupported during what was already a stressful process.

Unfortunately, we ultimately had to pull out of the house purchase following a poor survey. When I contacted the solicitor’s secretary to discuss this, I was disappointed by the lack of empathy shown. At one point, they even chuckled while I was speaking to them on the phone, which I found particularly inappropriate given the circumstances and the stress we were experiencing.

I subsequently made a formal complaint, but unfortunately not all of the points I had raised were addressed. I was also concerned to discover that the person dealing with my complaint had the same surname as the solicitor who had been handling my case. This raised concerns for me about whether the complaint was being dealt with independently and impartially.

By this stage, the whole experience had caused me considerable stress, and I decided not to pursue my complaint any further.

As a first-time buyer, this was a very disappointing introduction to the conveyancing process. I expected communication, guidance and basic customer service, but unfortunately felt that I received very little of these.

Since then, I have instructed another local solicitor for my legal work, and the difference has been remarkable. They have provided fantastic service, respond directly to my queries and have made me feel supported throughout the process.

Based on my experience, I would strongly recommend first-time buyers consider their options carefully and choose a conveyancer who will communicate clearly and provide the support and guidance they need.

Donna and Kelly were a great support throughout the process of purchasing my new build. I always received a quick responses when I had any queries or concerns, they were professional, clear and concise at every stage and quickly adapted to any issues that arose. The costs were very reasonable and I would definitely recommend them to anyone who is buying a new build.

We used this company acitvwas recommended and we could not have been any happier. It was for a house sale and house purchase, Donna Moore and her team were brilliant, they kept us well informed of progress and got it over the line in the end.

We recently completed the purchase of our new home and couldn't be happier with the service we received from Donna Moore and the team at Malcolm C. Foy.

Donna was incredibly helpful throughout the whole process, always keeping us updated and responding quickly to any questions we had. Buying a house can be stressful, but her professionalism, knowledge and friendly approach made everything much easier and gave us confidence every step of the way.

The transaction was handled smoothly from start to finish and we always felt well informed. We'd have no hesitation in recommending Donna and Malcolm C. Foy to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive solicitor.

Thank you again for all your hard work and for helping us secure our new home!

My first time purchasing a house and having a need for a solicitor and it has been a seamless experience, Donna Moore and her team have been exceptional and made this journey a memorable one. They really did an amazing job.

Excellent service from Donna & Kelly when buying our new build property. Process ran smoothly from start to finish. Would definitely recommend for anyone buying a new build.

I contacted MCF solicitors at Rotherham branch as I am located here, but I was relocated to Doncaster Branch for some reason and that was crucial. It was about 15 years ago when I bought business and have to transfer lease into my name. It took them nearly a year to do so and I have received letter saying that because it takes so long we have to charge you 300GBP, so I took letter from Doncaster Branch and visited Mr. Malcolm personally about this letter as I respond and reply to all communication same or next day. Mr Malcolm took letter and said its all sorted don't worry about it. Should have left them after this experience but didn't learn my lesson.
After lease comes to renewal in 2024 I contacted Rotherham Branch but was relocated again to Doncaster one. After over a year my patience gone, I decided to find another solicitor to renew the lease because of their hard work. I ended up with 501 GBP bill in 2026 and wasted over a year with them, hopefully you find this useful and make your decision if you want to contact MCF solicitors. Luckily No More MCF for me!